Let’s face it - picking the right cologne is hard: from the hundreds of choices at Nordstrom, to the thousands more online. That includes products from classic perfumers like Tom Ford and YSL, to newcomers like Hawthorne and Noteworthy, setting out to prove that you don’t need to spend $150 on your signature scent. That’s why our grooming experts reviewed hundreds of top colognes to find the 5 best colognes of 2024, based on scent, quality, and cost. Read on to find out our best colognes by category, along with our overall winner (spoiler alert: it’s a GQ award-winning, versatile cologne from Hawthorne – for just $50).

‍

Best Overall Cologne: Warm & Aromatic by Hawthorne

Scent Notes: Tonka, Bergamot, Cedarwood, Lavender

Scent Snapshot: Attention-Grabbing on a Dinner Date

Price: $50

Our top overall pick is a modern, versatile crowd pleaser. Hawthorne’s Warm & Aromatic is the new standard for men’s cologne in 2024. Hawthorne has worked with some of the most sought-after perfumers in cologne to deliver a scent that rivals the most luxurious colognes on the market. At just $50, it absolutely outclasses other options at this price point, and our experts actually ranked it above luxury brands priced over 3x higher.

Warm & Aromatic is designed by Quentin Bisch, who has won awards for his work with top brands like Gucci, YSL, Commes des Garcons, Jean Paul Gaultier. It’s a captivating and sophisticated scent with a combination of fresh wood and attention-grabbing notes, comparable to Tom Ford’s $295 Fougère D’Argent. Think casual suit, dinner date, perfect evening - our editors received compliments on their first day testing it. And if you don’t like the scent, there’s no risk – Hawthorne offers a 30-day money-back guarantee.

Pros: Modern scent, long lasting, affordable, money-back guarantee

Cons: Doesn’t have the name recognition of other brands

‍

Best Luxury Cologne: Tobacco Vanille by Tom Ford

Scent Notes: Tonka Bean, Vanilla, Cocoa

Scent Snapshot: Poker Table at a Country Club

Price: $295

Developed in 2007, Tobacco Vanille is one of Tom Ford’s most highly-rated scents. It’s a classic formula designed to evoke the feeling of sophistication, with a potent and distinctive sweet and smoky scent. Think country club or poker parlor – opulent luxury with the bold scent of tobacco.

Pros: Classic formula, very strong, long-lasting

Cons: Expensive, tobacco scent can be polarizing

‍

Best Cologne for Summer: Canary Diamond by Hawthorne

Scent Notes: Smoked pineapple, sea salt, sweet musk

Scent Snapshot: Smoked Citrus on the Beach

Price: $60

Whether you’re at the beach, the bar next to the pool, or on a first date, Canary Diamond is the perfect scent for summer. It shares a similar DNA as the cult classic Creed Aventus, a $495 cologne, but has its own unique and more modern character. The smoked pineapple and sea salt evoke white sand and crystal clear water, and the freshness of this scent will leave a lasting impression. Let’s not mistake that this cologne is a summer hit; it’s made by Rodrigo Flores-Roux, who is the nose behind the summer bestseller Tom Ford Neroli Portofino ($295). At $60, Canary Diamond is hands down our go-to summer night out fragrance.

Pros: Unique, fresh scent, universally loved, affordable

Cons: Not the best for colder winter months

‍

​​

The Safe Bet: Sauvage by Dior

Scent Notes: Bergamot, Sichuan pepper, patchouli

Scent Snapshot: Rooftop Lounge at Sunset

Price: $120

As one of the most popular colognes on the market for almost a decade, you can’t go wrong with this scent. With a distinct spicy fragrance that features notes of Sichuan pepper and pink peppercorn, it’s a great option if you’re looking for something bolder. However, its status as the top-selling cologne for the past 5 years means it’s a run-of-the-mill scent: you won’t be the only guy at the bar with this on.

Pros: Classic, fresh scent, mid-range price point

Cons: Won’t stand out in a crowd, 1 in 4 guys will be wearing this

‍

Best Cologne for Whiskey Lovers: Dark Suede by Hawthorne

Scent Notes: Tennessee whiskey, cashmere wood, green fig

Scent Snapshot: Old Fashioned at a Private Record Bar

Price: $60

Picture this: you walk down the stairs at the back of a liquor shop to a hidden speakeasy. After giving the password to get in, you sit at the bar and order an old fashioned made with a vintage single malt whiskey. That’s what this cologne smells like. It’s sweet but sophisticated, distinct yet smooth. This is definitely our choice for a classy evening event or cocktail bar – it’s smooth, bold, and masculine. And we found out that it is made by Olivier Gillotin, the same nose behind the $295 Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille, another top pick on our list.

‍Pros: Unique whiskey scent, masculine, mysterious

Cons: Distinct scent is not for those who don't like whiskey

‍

While there is no shortage of great cologne options for men, we’ve found Hawthorne colognes to be in a class of their own when it comes to premium, refined scents at an approachable price.

Don’t just take our word for it, though – find out why Hawthorne has become the go-to scent for our editors: